Benchmark Duel: Mac vs. PC, Round II
Page 2 of 3


3. Data Project
This test concentrates on animating layers from Photoshop and Illustrator. It animates randomly sequenced 1s and 0s traveling across the screen at different rates. Green lights were also added, making this the kind of graphic that might be used as a background for statistics in a production. The text elements were imported into After Effects as a three-layered Illustrator file. Since these are vector graphics, they could be scaled to any resolution within After Effects without diminishing their resolution. After the text layers were skewed using 3D effects, lighting effects were added to give the numbers a green cast. This kind of project is indicative of many text animation sequences that are commonly created in compositing software.




4. Gambler
This project was originally intended to be exported to the SWF (Shockwave Flash) format, but we processed it in 720x486 (QuickTime and AVI) pixels to see how our contestants could render this composite of Illustrator files in a more broadcast-bound situation. It's a good example of a 2D graphic composite that originated in Illustrator, which is many compositors' bread-and-butter.
[an error occurred while processing this directive]

5. Source Shapes
Here's another pure graphic of Illustrator files. This time the shapes are moved around in a 3D environment using a camera in After Effects. The graphic was originally designed in 2D, and when it was imported into After Effects, it retained its 2D composition while being moved around in 3D space. It started as a single multi-layered Illustrator file, and its individual layers were manipulated in After Effects to achieve this fly-around effect.




6. Virtual Set
Here's the most render-intensive graphic in our test. Using still photographs, an entire 3D environment is created within After Effects. The project involves constructing a room with walls and a ceiling, and then placing various graphics of pipes and gauges into the 3D space. Then, a camera is moved through the space, giving a 3D point of view. Again the PC left the Mac in the dust, taking only 7:39 to render the segment, with the Mac trailing at nearly 12 minutes to finish rendering the exact same sequence.

Click graphic for Amazon low price
Click graphic for Amazon's lowest price

If you would like to replicate these tests for yourself, pick up the book After Effects 5.5 Magic that includes a CD containing these AE project files (and many more) along with all the media you'll need to exactly reproduce our results. Special thanks to After Effects 5.5 Magic's author Mark Christiansen and the book's editor, Nathan Moody, as well as New Riders Publishing for giving us permission to use materials from this excellent book. Highly recommended.

Prev 1 2 3 Next

Related sites: • Creative MacDigital Post ProductionDigital ProducerDigital Video EditingDV FormatMedia Workstation
Related forums:


[an error occurred while processing this directive]